Exercise – Shell Directional Policy Matrix

This exercise asks you to apply the Shell Directional Policy Matrix to Brackwater Industrial.

The Scenario: Brackwater Industrial

The Shell Directional Policy Matrix: nine named positions from Leader to Divest

Brackwater Industrial is a capital-intensive engineering group with three divisions. Its board must decide where next year’s capital goes.

Marine coatings. The sector grows slowly but margins have held steady for fifteen years and supply is secure. Brackwater is the clear market leader, with the lowest cost base and a research team competitors cannot match.

Battery casings. The sector is expanding rapidly and margins are good, though several better-funded entrants have appeared. Brackwater entered late, holds a small share, and its production line is a generation behind.

Legacy pipework. Demand has fallen every year for a decade and margins are thin. Brackwater holds a modest share, an ageing plant, and no research activity in the area.

Your task
Judge each division on sector prospects and on competitive capabilities, place it on the grid, and give it the named Shell strategy that follows — Leader, Try Harder, Double or Quit, Growth, Custodial, Phased Withdrawal, Cash Generation or Divest. Then say which division the board should fund, and what the model implies about funding it only partly.

Once you have drafted your own answer, compare it with Marketing Teacher’s suggested answer.

One of four portfolio analysis models
Boston Matrix  ·  GE Business Screen  ·  Shell Directional Policy Matrix  ·  ADL Matrix
See how they compare, and when the extra detail is worth it, on portfolio analysis.
Written by Marketing Teacher.
Online course · certificate on completion
Study a full online course — and earn a certificate
Three courses that turn the free lessons into ordered modules, written at university Levels 4 to 6, with a short quiz after each.
See the online courses
Teaching this topic?

The slides, worksheet, lesson plan and poster for this lesson are free to download and free to use in your course — no sign-up, no permission needed.

See the teacher resources →